Right to Manage

Supreme Court Backs Leaseholders: A Missed Invitation No Longer Sinks an RTM Claim

The Supreme Court has ruled that failing to send one qualifying leaseholder a notice inviting participation does not automatically invalidate a Right to Manage claim. Here is what happened at Cresta Court, what the court decided, and what it means for your RTM claim.

The UK Supreme Court building on Parliament Square in autumn
In this article
Share this article

On 27 August 2026 the Supreme Court handed down its decision in Avon Freeholds Ltd v Cresta Court E RTM Company Ltd [2026] UKSC 31. If an RTM company fails to send one qualifying leaseholder a notice inviting participation, does its whole claim fail? A unanimous court said no, not automatically. The Court of Appeal had held otherwise, and its decision has been overturned.

What Happened at Cresta Court

Cresta Court is a block of 20 flats on Hanger Lane, London W5. The leaseholders formed an RTM company to acquire the right to manage under the Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Act 2002.

Before serving a claim notice on the landlord, an RTM company must give a notice inviting participation to every qualifying tenant who is not already a member, or has not agreed to become one (section 78). The claim notice cannot be given until at least 14 days after those notices have gone out (section 79(2)).

The company sent notices inviting participation on 4 November 2021 and served its claim notice on 21 January 2022. One leaseholder, Ms O'Connor of Flat 17, was missed. Her lease had been granted in April 2020 but its registration at HM Land Registry was still pending, so she did not show up as the registered owner. She was never sent a notice inviting participation. A few days after the claim notice, she agreed to become a member of the RTM company and supported the claim.

The landlord argued that the omission made the claim notice invalid.

How the Case Reached the Supreme Court

The First-tier Tribunal and the Upper Tribunal both rejected the landlord's argument and found that the RTM company was entitled to acquire the right to manage. The Court of Appeal disagreed ([2025] EWCA Civ 1016), accepting the landlord's case that the failure to serve the notice made the claim notice void.

What the Supreme Court Decided

Lord Briggs gave the only judgment, with which Lord Reed, Lord Stephens, Lady Rose and Lord Snowden agreed. The court allowed the appeal and restored the Upper Tribunal's decision.

The key points of the reasoning were:

  • The Act does not say what happens if the rule is broken. Neither section 78(1) nor section 79(2) states that a claim notice is invalid if a notice inviting participation is missed. The court therefore looked at the purpose of the requirement and whether anyone could be prejudiced.
  • The rule protects leaseholders, not landlords. The notice inviting participation exists so that qualifying tenants have the chance to join the RTM company. Qualifying tenants have no statutory right to object to the acquisition of the right to manage in any event.
  • The 14-day rule is a timing rule. Lord Briggs described section 79(2) as being about the gap between the invitations and the claim notice, not a sanction for breaching section 78(1).
  • There is a separate remedy. Section 107 of the Act gives a discretionary power to order compliance with the RTM procedure. Since 3 March 2025 that power has belonged to the First-tier Tribunal rather than the court. That, rather than invalidity, is the appropriate route for a procedural default. The Supreme Court noted that a deliberate decision to send no invitations at all might properly lead to an order under section 107 on the application of the qualifying tenants affected.
  • Substance and procedure are different. A landlord can still challenge the substantive conditions of entitlement, such as whether the building qualifies, in its counter-notice. A breach of the procedural steps in sections 78 and 79 does not decide entitlement.

What This Means for RTM Claims

For leaseholders, this is a welcome decision. Identifying every qualifying tenant in a building is not always straightforward. Leases change hands and Land Registry registrations can take months. Until now, a single missed invitation could hand a landlord a technical argument to knock out an otherwise valid claim.

It is not a licence to cut corners. The decision concerned an honest omission affecting one leaseholder who went on to support the claim. RTM companies should still check the register and the leaseholders' own records carefully, and send invitations to every qualifying tenant who has not joined.

A Caution: Setting Up the Company Correctly Still Matters

A recent Upper Tribunal decision shows that some errors are still fatal. In Better Intelligent Management Ltd v Phoenix Place Block A RTM Company Ltd [2026] UKUT 257 (LC), decided on 8 July 2026, two RTM companies had been formed for two separate blocks in Liverpool. Both sets of articles of association described the premises as a single address covering both blocks. Because a company can only be an RTM company in relation to premises that qualify, the companies were not RTM companies when they served their first claim notices, and those notices had no legal effect.

The companies recovered the position by amending their articles and serving fresh claim notices, which were valid. The lesson is clear: the Supreme Court has taken a practical approach to procedural slips, but the foundations, including the description of the premises in the company's articles, must be right. Our guide on how to set up an RTM company explains what the articles need to say.

Our View

This is a sensible outcome. The RTM regime was designed to be a simple, no-fault route for leaseholders to take over management, and the Supreme Court has confirmed that landlords cannot use a harmless procedural slip to defeat it. Take care over the articles, the list of qualifying tenants and the notices. You can check whether your block is eligible in our guide, does my building qualify for Right to Manage?, and read about each stage in the Right to Manage process.

If you would like help taking over the management of your building, find out more about our Right to Manage service or call us on 020 3540 9996.

Share this article

This article is general information, not legal advice. Accurate as at 8 October 2026.

DT
Daniel Tang
Consultant Solicitor, Lease Advice Bureau

Daniel specialises in lease extensions, collective enfranchisement and the right to manage, acting for leaseholders across England and Wales.

About the team →

Have a question about your lease? We can help.

Have a no-obligation conversation with a specialist solicitor about your lease, your rights and your next step.

Questions about your lease?

Speak to a specialist solicitor, no obligation.

Get in touch
Privacy Policy
Disclaimer: the contents of this site do not constitute legal advice and should not be relied upon as a substitute for legal counsel
linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram