Right to Manage vs Buying the Freehold: Which Is Better?

Right to Manage gives leaseholders control of management with no premium; collective enfranchisement gives ownership of the freehold. How the two compare on qualification, cost, time, risk and lease extensions.

Residents chatting outside the entrance of a London mansion block

If your building is badly run, there are two statutory routes to take control of it. Right to Manage (RTM) lets leaseholders take over the management without buying anything. Collective enfranchisement lets them buy the freehold outright. Both are powerful, both need at least half the flats to take part, and they suit different buildings and different budgets. This guide sets out how they compare as the law stands in September 2026.

One point comes before any comparison: how your leases are structured. If your lease is between you and the freeholder only (a bipartite lease), the freeholder holds the management obligations, so buying the freehold brings management with it. If a separate management company is also a party to your lease (a tripartite lease), the repairing, insurance and service charge obligations usually sit with that company. Buying the freehold then gives you ownership but not, by itself, control of management. Check your lease before choosing a route.

What Each Right Gives You

Right to Manage comes from Chapter 1 of Part 2 of the Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Act 2002. An RTM company formed by the leaseholders takes over the landlord's management functions: services, repairs, maintenance, insurance and the appointment of contractors or a managing agent. Where a management company is a party to the leases, its management functions pass to the RTM company as well (section 96). The freeholder still owns the building and still receives the ground rent. Nothing about your lease changes.

Collective enfranchisement comes from Chapter 1 of Part 1 of the Leasehold Reform, Housing and Urban Development Act 1993. The participating leaseholders buy the freehold through a nominee purchaser, usually a company they own. You and your neighbours become the landlord. In a bipartite building that also puts you in charge of management. In a tripartite building, the management company stays a party to every lease and keeps its functions unless the leaseholders also take those over.

Side by Side

PointRight to ManageCollective enfranchisement
What you getManagement of the building, including the functions of any management company that is a party to the leasesOwnership of the freehold. Management comes with it only where the leases are bipartite
Price paid to the freeholderNoneA premium set by a statutory formula
Freeholder's legal costsNot payable on an uncontested claim (since 3 March 2025)Currently payable by the leaseholders; due to change, no start date yet
Participation neededAt least half the flatsAt least half the flats
Non-residential limitUp to 50% of internal floor areaUp to 25% of internal floor area
Lease extensions afterwardsNo change: still negotiated with or claimed from the freeholderYour own company can grant them

Qualification

The two rights share a core test. The building must be self-contained (or a self-contained part of a building), contain at least two flats, and at least two thirds of the flats must be held by qualifying tenants, meaning leaseholders whose leases were originally granted for more than 21 years. In both cases, leaseholders of at least half the flats must join in: for RTM they must be members of the RTM company on the date of the claim (section 79(5)), and for enfranchisement they must give the initial notice (section 13(2)). In a two-flat building, both must take part.

The key difference is commercial space. Since 3 March 2025, a building can qualify for RTM if up to 50% of its internal floor area (excluding common parts) is non-residential. The Leasehold and Freehold Reform Act 2024 also raises the enfranchisement limit to 50%, but that change has not yet been brought into force, so for a freehold purchase the limit is still 25% (section 4 of the 1993 Act). A building with shops making up, say, 40% of its floor area can therefore use RTM but cannot currently buy its freehold under the statute.

There are other differences at the margins. For enfranchisement, a person who owns more than two flats in the building does not count as a qualifying tenant of any of them. Both rights exclude certain small converted buildings of no more than four units where the freeholder, or an adult member of their family, lives in one of the flats. Our guide on whether your building qualifies for Right to Manage covers the RTM tests in more detail.

Cost

This is where the two routes differ most. RTM involves no payment to the freeholder for the building. Since 3 March 2025, the freeholder also cannot recover its own costs of an uncontested RTM claim from the leaseholders, although a tribunal can still order the RTM company to pay costs where the claim notice is withdrawn or ceases to have effect and the company acted unreasonably in giving it or in not withdrawing it sooner. The company also pays the reasonable costs of anyone who supplies information in response to its information notice. The realistic outlay is your own legal fees, company formation and, if the claim is disputed, tribunal costs. Our guide to the costs of Right to Manage gives a breakdown.

Enfranchisement means buying an asset. The premium is calculated under Schedule 6 of the 1993 Act and reflects the freeholder's ground rent income, its interest in the building when the leases end, and, where any participating lease has 80 years or less to run, half of the marriage value. On top of that, the participants pay their own solicitor and valuer, and the freeholder's reasonable legal and valuation costs under section 33 of the 1993 Act. The 2024 Act will change both. On costs, it replaces section 33 with a rule that each side generally bears its own costs, bringing enfranchisement into line with RTM. The government consulted on the detail between 15 July and 23 September 2026, so this change is moving, but it is not in force and no start date has been announced. Until it starts, budget for the freeholder's costs, and check the position again before your initial notice is served. See how much collective enfranchisement costs for a full breakdown.

Time and Risk

An RTM claim notice must give the freeholder at least one month to serve a counter-notice, and the date on which the RTM company takes over must be at least three months after that. An uncontested claim therefore takes over management at least four months after the claim notice is given. If the freeholder disputes the claim, the tribunal decides.

Enfranchisement usually takes longer. The freeholder has at least two months to respond to the initial notice, the parties then negotiate the price, and if terms are not agreed an application must be made to the tribunal within six months of the counter-notice or the claim is treated as withdrawn. Under the current costs rules, a withdrawn claim leaves the participants paying the freeholder's costs with nothing to show for it.

Management vs Ownership

With RTM, the RTM company must run the building in line with the leases. It collects service charges and must account for them, but it cannot change the leases, cannot grant lease extensions, and does not receive the ground rent. The freeholder keeps its ownership and is entitled to become a member of the RTM company once the company takes over.

With enfranchisement, the nominee purchaser owns the building and is the landlord of every flat, including those whose owners did not take part. It collects the ground rent, can vary leases by agreement, and decides what happens to any development potential such as roof space. In a tripartite building, though, the day-to-day management stays with the management company named in the leases, unless the leaseholders already control it or take its functions over through RTM.

Lease Extensions After You Own the Freehold

This is often the deciding factor. Once the participants own the freehold through their company, the company can grant each participant a lease extension on whatever terms the participants have agreed, commonly a 999-year term at a peppercorn rent with no premium. That removes the marriage value problem for good. In a tripartite building, the management company will usually need to join in the new leases. Non-participants keep their statutory right to extend, but they claim it against your company and pay a premium to it.

RTM does nothing for lease length. If your leases are short or approaching 80 years, RTM will not help with the cost of extending them. Our guide on what happens when your lease falls below 80 years explains why that matters.

Which Should You Choose?

RTM is usually the better fit where:

  • your main complaint is poor management, high service charges or an unresponsive managing agent;
  • your leases are tripartite and the management company is the problem, because buying the freehold alone would not remove it;
  • most leases are long, so extensions are not pressing;
  • neighbours will not or cannot fund a premium;
  • the building has between 25% and 50% commercial floor space, so enfranchisement is not currently available.

Enfranchisement is usually the better fit where:

  • several leases are short or approaching 80 years, so extensions are coming anyway;
  • enough neighbours can fund the premium and costs;
  • you want control over ground rent, lease terms and future development, and your leases are bipartite (or you are prepared to use RTM for the management side too);
  • the freeholder's conduct makes a permanent exit more attractive than a management takeover.

RTM First, Freehold Later

The two rights are separate, and having an RTM company does not stop the leaseholders buying the freehold later. Some buildings take RTM first to fix management quickly and cheaply, then enfranchise once funds and participation are in place. In a tripartite building this may be the only way to control both: RTM takes over the management company's functions, and enfranchisement delivers the ownership that RTM cannot. The freehold purchase needs its own nominee purchaser: an RTM company's articles follow a form prescribed by regulations that confines it to managing the building, so it is not a suitable vehicle for buying the freehold.

Not sure which route suits your building?

We can look at your leases and building and tell you which route works, including where a management company is involved. Call us on 020 3540 9996.

Right to Manage Freehold purchase Get Advice

This guide is general information about the law in England and Wales as at September 2026 and is not legal advice on your circumstances.

Privacy Policy
Disclaimer: the contents of this site do not constitute legal advice and should not be relied upon as a substitute for legal counsel
linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram